Dr. William Lane Craig is widely regarded as the paragon of Christian scholarship. His voluminous writings, debates, and lectures have left an indelible mark on Christian apologetics, theology, and philosophy. As a stalwart defender of the historic Christian faith, he has repelled countless attacks, demonstrating that Christian thinkers are a formidable force to be reckoned with. His latest magnum opus, In Quest for the Historical Adam, has sparked intense debate, rivaling the attention garnered by his previous works. What's striking, however, is that the controversy surrounding this book emanates not from outside the faith, but from within. Craig's provocative claims strike at the very heart of classical orthodox theology, leaving many Christians uneasy about his conclusions. Through a meticulous examination of philosophical arguments, biblical exegesis, evolutionary theory, and interdisciplinary analysis, Craig embarks on a quest to determine whether the Adam of Genesis was a real, historical figure. This essay provides a critical assessment of Craig's arguments and conclusions, mirroring the structure of his book.